8 min read
Moving From Traditionally Published to Self-Published
Written by:
Becky Connolly
Sue Bentley is an award-winning, Sunday Times bestselling traditionally published and self-published author, who has written 80 novels across adult and children’s fiction including the very popular children series the Rainbow Magic and Magic Kitten.
So what did Sue Bentley’s publishing journey look like? How did her publishing journey begin, and what led her switch from traditional to self-publishing?
Fostering a Love of Reading and Writing
Sue has had a love of reading since she was very young: “I’ve loved books and reading since I discovered the local public library at a young age. I’m from a large, working class family and we lived in a council house. No one else was mad about books like me. I worked for Northamptonshire Libraries from leaving school aged sixteen, which gave me the chance to indulge my passion for books.”
However, it wasn’t until Sue was married and her children started school that Sue started considering writing.
“I had set my mind on learning the craft and getting published, while still holding down a job and bringing up a family. My goal was for it to be my future, my long-term career. I met two other women at a local writing event. We began meeting to discuss our writing and offer each other constructive advice. They both shared my passion to see their work in print – at the time that meant being traditionally published, by one of the many publishing houses. This was long before all the mergers and the resulting Big Five. The only alternative then was something called ‘Vanity Publishing’, which everyone warned you about. The self-publishing industry had not developed into the sophisticated industry it is today.”
The Start of a Writing Career
Before Sue began writing novels, she began writing for a local magazine.
“I wrote a few articles and features for a local magazine, and was paid for them. This was the first step into professional writing and I accumulated dozens of rejection letters from various traditional publishers.”
“Then, the opportunity arose to submit three chapters and an outline to Virgin Publishing for their new Black Lace list – erotica for women written by women. To my amazement, I had a phone call to say the editor loved my partial and wanted to commission the book. The Captive Flesh by Cleo Cordell. (First of many pen-names) won erotic novel of the year. I went on to write seven erotic novels for Black Lace. Writing as Susan Swann, I wrote five more for XLibris, a division of LittleBrown.”
However, the publishing journey wasn’t always smooth. “I’ve always loved reading gothic fiction, with a touch of horror. Books like Dracula, Frankenstein, and have been influenced by Anne Rice, Tanith Lee, and more recently Johanna Van Veen. After moving on from erotic fiction, I was commissioned by Signet, to write a gothic romance/horror trilogy. I’d completed two of the three titles, when there were complications and the deal fell through. It was devastating. For a while I thought it was the end of my writing career.”
Publishing Popular Children’s Books
After this experience, Sue’s agent recommended a new angle for her writing. “My agent suggested I explore an opportunity to write for an established children’s series. It was not an easy transition, and quite a challenge. But I persevered, and my first title as Lucy Daniels for Animal Ark was Horse in the House. I gathered more pen names, while writing for children. Daisy Meadows, for some of the early titles in the Rainbow Magic series. Kate Bloom for another fairy series.”
“The opportunity arose to write my own children’s series. As Sue Bentley, my Magic Kitten, Magic Puppy, Magic Ponies, and Magic Bunny books have been published in translation around the world. One of them made the Sunday Times bestseller list.”

Sue's incredibly successful children's series, Rainbow Magic and Magic Kitten.=
A Move Back To Adult Fiction, and The Creation of Flesh Endures
Sue had incredible success with her children’s fiction, however, still felt she was missing something. “My love of darkly disturbing gothic fiction wouldn’t release its hold,” she says. “In recent years I’ve returned to writing books for adults. We Other by Sue Bentley set in the here and now, and a dark, dangerous world that exists alongside it, has pitiless fae, a family curse and first love. Second Skin by Sue Bentley is set in a time of conflict, with a fierce race of shape-changers, two people on different sides caught up in it, discover a forbidden love.”
“Currently, I have a completed novel, a chilling, gothic mystery set in Victorian times, out on submission. While waiting for it to find a publisher, I decided to take another look at the gothic-romance, horror books I originally wrote for Signet, now long out of print, forgotten and gathering dust in my study.”
“I fell in love with the characters all over again. The immortal Lord Karolan, whose intimate touch brings death to any lover, and whose only companion is his greedy ‘familiar’. And Garnetta, who Karolan saves from the plague sweeping through Europe by giving her the ‘dark gift’ without her permission. I decided to edit the book and bring out a new edition. This became Flesh Endures, written by Sue C. Bentley, to signify that this book, and subsequent books in a similar vein, will be the darkest, dark of my gothic writing.”
Opting for Full-Service Self-Publishing
After a successful career traditionally publishing her titles, it was time for Sue to take the plunge into self-publishing. “It would be a challenge, but I love to learn new things,” she says.
“I knew from conversations with other writers, and posts on social media platforms, that there were different ways to self-publish. Many self-published authors used popular, direct digital platforms, or companies that produced their books, but most of these methods did not include PR or marketing. Writers spoke about how difficult it was to bring their books to the notice of readers. I wondered how I would manage, when I hadn’t the heavy machinery of a traditional publisher, and their investment of time and money working to my advantage.”
“I have some titles with a digital-first publisher, as ebooks and print-on-demand. Which makes them available worldwide and, caters to the many people who read on various devices, Kindle, Kobo etc. That can work very well for many authors.”
Sue, however, had certain things she knew she wanted from her publisher. “Whilst a digital-first publisher can work well for many authors, it’s unlikely that a digital publisher will be prepared to invest in you for a print run. And this is something I knew I wanted for Flesh Endures. I needed it to be available in bookshops, and for there to be physical books, as well as digital books available in libraries. A print-run would also mean a local indie-book shop, or Waterstones, could order in my books, and sell them, when I was appearing at literary festivals, and other author events.”
“In short I wanted the closest experience to traditional publishing I could find. Because I would be investing in myself this time, and I wanted to get it right.”
Deciding to Publish with Troubador
“So I searched for a publishing company who could fulfil all my needs,” Sue says. “They needed to have a great reputation for producing high-quality books. But also do some of the PR, and marketing to the trade, and what about ongoing author support? It seemed a lot to ask. After a lot of research and consideration, only one publishing company suited all my needs. I chose full-service publishing with Troubador. They’re an established company of 30 years. Not only do they work closely with authors at every stage of production, they produce high-quality books with stunning covers, designed in house. They also actually want you to sell your books and will help you do it.”

Sue Bentley with her title, Flesh Endures, on BBC Radio Northampton
“Troubador have a close affiliation with Waterstones and will store your books in their own warehouse. Where they deal with all trade orders, and those purchased directly from their own on-line shop. Authors have access to all their information via the author’s hub, and can see at a glance how sales are doing, whether book stock is getting low, and what royalties have been earned.”
“I have found Troubador excellent to work with. Everyone is efficient and helpful. They are completely transparent about costs and services. You make your own informed choice about which of their services you choose to buy.”
Sue’s First Experience Self-Publishing
So, how did full-service self-publishing compare to traditional publishing? “It was more time-consuming than I’d imagined, after having had so much of the background work done for me with my extensive experience of traditional publishing. Many decisions were made ‘in house’ without my input, with my previous books, including cover designs, which is the norm,” she says.
“The upside of being so involved at every stage with Troubador, is the measure of control and input you have over all of the production services. Nothing goes ahead until you’re fully satisfied. From the early stages when you choose paper weight and fonts, up to when you sign-off your books to go to print, and eventually unbox your first finished copies. It was particularly rewarding to work with Chloé, the in-house book cover designer. She interpreted my ideas and thoughts into something far more stunning than I could ever have imagined. The professionalism of all the team is outstanding.”
“I felt, and still feel, that I am one of Troubador’s authors, not simply a client.”
“I do think it helps enormously with going this route to full-service self-publishing, if you have a clear idea of what you want. As I did. Everything was done to make the experience as smooth as possible. But if you need extra help, or things explaining, as we all do, now and then, there is always someone who can answer your queries or set your mind at rest.”
Sue at a bookshop event for Flesh Endures
What’s Next?
“I’m working on another dark gothic fantasy/romance/horror. I intend to self-publish this one too. It’s at the editing stage and will be ready in the coming months. I know with Troubador it will be in very safe hands.”
Becky Connolly
Turning a Passion into a Profession
Becky Connolly
Being Listed In UK's Top 100 Most Influential People: Author Steve Hill MBE
Becky Connolly
Marketing Wins: Industry Experts to Published Authors
Becky Connolly
Our Author's Journey to a Film, an Exhibition and an Award: The Power of Self-Publishing
Crafting a Fantasy Legacy: Daniel T. Jackson’s Self-Publishing Story
Alex Thompson
